The Charlie Brown Question

Posted under NOTEBOOK

finn-brown-header

“I going kill myself.”

No sooner did it leave his lips than I pounced on his statement with a question.

“Where did you hear that?”

His little formative 3-year-old mind had already moved on to more fertile pastures, a grouping of Lego blocks for the moment.

“Where did you hear that, Finn?”

I didn’t want to scare or provoke my little son, but the surging tension in my vocal cords betrayed my heart. I wasn’t ready for that. I don’t know that any parent ever could be, but I certainly wasn’t ready for it thirty-six months into the game. I’m usually the calm one.

“Charlie Brown say it.”

Charlie Brown is awkward.Awkward isn’t the only thing Charlie is selling. Apparently.

And there it was. I yanked open the file cabinet drawers of my experience searching for every instance I could recall of Charlie Brown’s self-deprecation. Every ounce of his “woe-is-me” bullshit. There were many.

And I hated myself for it.

Apparently, more than one bald-headed kid has had a non-optimum influence on my son.

But I hate writing this even now. Acknowledging it. Focusing the spotlight on this thing. This is his story to tell, not mine. Hell, he probably won’t even remember it.

“Do you know what that means?”

He didn’t. He was downright chipper. How could he grasp it? But there was a glimmer, an echo of resonance. He understood it meant something painful. Unpleasant, at least.

“It means you hurt yourself. Hurt more than anything.”

As a parent, you try so hard to place your child or children in a setting to thrive. You give them everything you can possibly provide. And then some. You share in the experience of watching them become people instead of fleshy marshmallow creatures. It’s magical. And complicated.

I’ve tried to offer my history to him through old cartoons, photos of my life and visiting places I used to play. Little did I know that those old places were filled with lead paint and sharp edges, those old cartoons rife with coarse themes. And now, they’ve given my son something to unconsciously parrot back to me.

Have I failed him?

I’m no helicopter parent. I’m not a fan of raising children in plastic bubbles. And these nostalgic tokens I’ve shown him of my past built me in many ways, good and bad, but I feel… responsible. I recognize he didn’t quite grasp what he was saying, but this is the moment when we start learning, both of us, that saying things we don’t mean can have consequences. That words are symbols for emotion and action.

And I’ve discovered that I’m not afraid of his frailty. I’m afraid of mine.

30 Comments

  • shane says:

    I feel you man. I hate it when Isaac says something negative …something I know he got from me. Dont beat yourself up though…think of ten things your kid did yesterday to bring you joy. 10-1. Not such a bad day right! Good teachable moment for both of you!!

  • S says:

    Heart stopping moment Charlie. You handled the conversation brilliantly.

  • Leighann says:

    You handled it well. I wish I could say that’ll be it for the “go away world, leave my kid alone” moments…but it’s just beginning. As long as you and mom are there to field the questions and help him think things through, he’ll be just fine. 🙂

  • Momo Fali says:

    Sometimes, I just want to curl up with Linus’s blanket and pretend my kids will stay innocent forever.

  • Mollie says:

    I never realized how terribly negative Charlie Brown was until my kids started watching/reading it. Lucy is a total asshole. Charlie Brown is a doormat with horrible self-esteem. The rest of the kids are mean to each other constantly. How did this comic become so beloved?

    • WeirdFish says:

      Think of the time period and degrees of social acceptance. Children’s self-esteem? Phah! That just means the kid needs toughening up!

      Bullies beating you up on the playground? HIT ‘EM BACK!

      Those who love the nostalgia (key word there) forget the negative, or that they readily IDENTIFIED with Charlie Brown’s tribulations, while still accepting the fact that hey, at least *I* don’t have it so bad.

      Nowadays, we have the Thought Police as well as the Child-Rearing Police undercover and just waiting to tattle on us if we do something that They deem “inappropriate.”

      Out litigious society today would have its butt handed back to it by our previous generation.

      This is why. In our mindless efforts to become “better parents,” we’ve become insulated and paranoid instead. Yes, Lucy was a jerk — she was meant to be.

      Does everything think that Charles Schultz DIDN’T base her on someone he actually knew, or an amalgamation of personalities that he grew up with?

  • K-chan says:

    We’ve watched a few Charlie Brown shows together as a family now. I too was horrified to see how poorly the characters acted to each other. I seemed to enjoy the comic books as a kid and I want to re-read them as an adult before letting my kids read them, but generally they seemed deeper and less stereotyped than the show.

    What we have done when we watch the shows, is clearly verbalize how we feel about the character’s actions. So when Lucy says or does something wrong, we say “I don’t like this, what she is doing is unkind” or “That is not right” or something along those lines. It seems to help – my kids have become aware of that and been able to tell me of times when they saw something “unkind”.

    My husband took my daughter to see Porco Rosso a few weeks ago and it definitely was upsetting to her (oops). We talked afterward and she told me about the things she saw that were “not right” such as “laughing when trying to hurt someone” and “punching someone” and I explained that sometimes there will be things in shows we see that we don’t agree with.

  • Monica says:

    Charlie,

    I look back now at things I did as a kid or things I watched and I am amazed. I agree that we can’t keep our kids in a bubble but some things just shouldn’t be aimed at a child. So much violence and words that don’t mean much to the child but can tear us apart to hear such things. I fear the day when my 2 year old starts school because he will be exposed to so much that I won’t be able to control. When I was in High School, I heard 1st graders cussing and talking about sex and I think they knew more than I did. This scares me.

    You haven’t failed him. He doesn’t even understand it, but as parents we have to have these conversations with our kids when we see these things. We have to keep the conversations going so even when they are exposed to it, we can help shape how they deal with it. You have plenty of time Charlie. But always keep the communication open and honest with your son. I know I will have to as well.

  • Kathryn says:

    I think you handled this awesomely! Many parents would not acknowledge what their kid said, or laugh it off. I think this is where being a good parent comes in. You talk to your kid about the hard/awkward/etc. things that maybe we think they are too young to talk about it, or whatever. You handled it in a way that aknowledged him, and what he said, in an age appropriate way. I wish every day that I could keep my daughter sheltered and innocent, and I can…until she goes into school. Establishing a relationship now, where we talk about those things w/ no judgement or anger, but calmly and openly, will go a long way in keeping those lines of communication open when things get more serious. I am somewhat afraid of this day, but I really believe setting the stage for it now, with calm and open communication will help a lot. You sound like an awesome daddy, you can handle it!

  • Calley says:

    I’ve been dealing with those painful words for a few years now. My now 10 yr old seems to think they are the words he needs to say when he is frustrated at school or home. Sadly at 10 he does know what they mean and that they hurt me very badly. All you can do is keep loving them and pray that they understand how much you love them and how badly that would hurt you. Stay strong!

  • Oh Charlie! It’s okay. You haven’t done anything wrong. One of the scariest things as a parent is seeing the innocence erode away, slowly but surely. Their first hurt. The first time they say something scary. The first time other kids are mean to them. It’s awful. You think, oh no!, I’m not ready. I find I’m never ready, but I do what I can in the moment, just like you did. Keep doing what you’re doing.

  • Rebecca says:

    bawling – I have a 22 month old sponge at home who is very into the myna bird stage right now & I’ve caught a few doozies already that, though from the mouths of babes, were learned from me…. mama gotta watch it now…. at least he didn’t “learn it from watching you” (ie: hear it from you)

  • Talk about having the football pulled out from you. I know this feeling… the realization of how thin and breakable your heart is as a parent… and the blame.
    What they say and what they understand is so tricky at this age. Go easy on yourself… and go give him some big fat hugs, smooches, and wrastle a little.

  • Willow M says:

    Ugh! Sucky moment! You are right about him prob not remembering it. Unfortunately, YOU will. Don’t beat yourself up. Kids are so much like sponges it’s ridiculous! One of the many reasons I have started actually paying attention to what the kids are watching on TV and what books/magazines they are looking at (my husband is a motorcycle guy and many of the mags he reads are NOT OK!). My 6yo said “I wish I were dead” about a year ago, I have no idea where he heard it but I was trying to not let the tears fall when we were talking about it. That’s the hard thing with little kids, they just don’t understand the meaning behind what they say or how badly it can hurt others. And it’s hard being a parent and not totally melting down at times like these. Keep your chin up, deary!

  • Thank you for sharing this experience, Charlie. That is one shitty moment to go through as a parent & it sounds like you handled it well. The stuff kids pick up baffles me. And they are so oblivious to the impact of their words. That part is the blessing of it all.

  • While my 3-yr-old son was getting blood drawn yesterday, he was crying hysterically and he yelled, “Oh my God.” I have no idea where he heard this. My wife and I try not to use the Lord’s name in vain. I am sure we slip from time to time. But he used it in the “appropriate” context, which was weird. I won’t worry until it becomes a habit 🙂

  • Kelly says:

    I feel for you but you have to remember that we had exposure to all of this and we turned out fine. We absolutely cannot make our children live in isolation or in a bubble…it will do them more harm than good when they get out in the real world. Jeez….do you know the mother dies in 3 out of 5 Disney movies? Horrible and horrifying…but the thought of it probably made me appreciate my mother all the more and think about the fact that she might not be there for me forever. There are lessons in all of this whether we see them or not.

  • jetts31 says:

    I actually let my voice raise so my kids understand the severity of whatever it is they said (I hate myself, I’m ugly, I’m fat, etc.). I want them to understand the reason I get upset is because they are far too awesome to accept those sorts of thoughts.
    I think I would rather hear them curse than hear those sorts of things.

  • Tim says:

    We were shocked when our 3 year-old son told us “I’m going to run away”. Turned out he’d just parroted it from “The Runaway Train” (the kids book not the Jon Voight movie).

    And don’t get me started on Beatrix Potter stories. Fluffy bunny wabbits and kittens with a hint of Stephen King.

    There are a lot of negative influences out in the world. All we can do is outweigh them with positives.

  • Laura says:

    I felt this way about Rudolph last Christmas, with my 2.5 year old – I clearly did not remember that movie well enough! Good gravy, right from the start I was having to interpret and clarify “wow that was really mean!” And it just didn’t stop! After about 5-10 min, I finally fast forwarded to the end (which he didn’t mind at all, since everyone was being so mean!) and it still wasn’t much better. Ended up shitting it off and, again, he didn’t mind (phew). I just kept thinking “*no one* (in any way related to our lives) talks to anyone that way anymore, where I think we understood that some people (maybe bosses or ??) were real bastards back then… It felt like it wasn’t even worth exposing him to.

  • Allie says:

    I was so excited to let my 4 year old watch Charlie Brown’s Christmas last December until it started. I had no idea they said the word stupid so many times or were so mean to each other! Luckily every time they said it he did the hand-over-mouth and said “well that’s not very nice!”

  • Liza Hippler says:

    Oh, man, that would have FREAKED me out. Sailor LOVES, LOVES Charlie Brown (well, Snoopy and Linus) and has some of the specials on the iPad. Watching all those old cartoons (she also loves the Smurfs) is like taking a whack on the head with all the crazy shit that comes out of their mouths!

  • Pedro says:

    It’s scary how fast they absorb things… and not only the good ones

  • Erich says:

    My 3 year-old daughter is a big fan of the show Rugrats, a cartoon that came out in the 90’s when I was still just an awkward teenager with no thoughts about how the shows I was watching would be seen by my children. When my daughter watches it now she seems quite focused on the way the characters interact. The character named Angelica is also 3 and tends to lord over the other characters who are infants to maybe 2 years of age. She often refers to them as the “stupid babies” and can be quite mean in general. My daughter asks me if she was making good or bad decisions as that’s the means we’re using to help guide good behavior. When Angelica calls Tommy a “stupid baby” we tell her that it was a bad decision which she understands. When Tommy shares his snack with Chuckie we tell her it’s a good decision which is then followed up with “because sharing is caring!”

    Charlie Brown, though, is different. We’ve watched the Christmas special as a family and my daughter was more concerned with the amount of Christmas lights rather than Charlie brown’s morose and depressed nature.

  • Matt says:

    I must say my son isn’t at that stage quite yet, but even seeing him mimic me slouching on the couch is difficult to take, let alone hearing something like this. I have written about how I have become somewhat emotional ever since having my son and stuff like this won’t be easy to swallow. It seems that you dealt with this brilliantly Charlie, I hope I handle it with as much pose as you seem to have.

  • Laurie says:

    Wow, I can’t even fathom how devastating that must have been to hear your little guy say that. Well done.

  • Amber says:

    I understand the arguments but…

    At the end of every episode, regardless of what happens, the kids in Peanuts adore and stand up for each other. Show me two best friends (in the real world) that don’t pick on each other in one way or another.

  • John says:

    Haven’t really had to deal with the idea of self inflicted death yet, thank goodness, but we had a pet die recently and we had to have a talk with my 3 year old about how everything that lives, eventually dies. It didn’t take her long to ask if our dog would die and then if mommy would die. It is not easy. The other day she finally applied it to herself and told me “but I don’t want to die, Daddy” and it about broke my heart. All we can do is be as gently honest as we can and try to help them understand.

  • Marilyn says:

    When my eldest son (now 4) was two, he was playing with toy guns with his cousins and ran up to me, handed me a little plastic gun, and said, “Shoot me, Mommy!” All smiles and laughter and fun. I said that no, I was not going to shoot him, never ever ever, and I made a hard & fast rule that NO ONE was allowed to play with guns around him again EVER, until he got old enough to understand the consequences.

    Yesterday he found a toy gun that had been hidden in the basement, and I figured if he was going to play with them, at least now I could begin teaching gun safety: finger off the trigger until you’re ready to fire, know what you’re shooting at & what’s beyond, know WHY you’re shooting whatever you’re shooting. Still makes my heart clench, but better to teach safety with a toy gun than let him turn 18 & get a real one with no previous guidance.

  • lw says:

    The kindys in southland new Zealand (where most men are into hunting) get gun licenses. They have to sign a piece of paper saying they’ll only shoot rabbits pigs and deer, and if they aim at anything else they lose their license

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *